Why?

What is your opinion on the state of our Nation? It is time WE start talking about and creating the country that we live in and love. Let's start discussing our country from our point of view, the people who live here


Saturday, May 28, 2011

When human rights are wrong

According to a 2001 Constitutional Court ruling the South African government cannot extradite someone suspected of a capital crime to a country that enforces the death penalty. The ruling does however allow for the extradition if the requesting government provides a commitment that they will not pass the death penalty.

A victory for human rights? I don't think so.

In the last few years two men from Botswana suspected of a capital offence (murder) have entered South Africa. The government of Botswana asked for these men to be extradited so that the cases can be put to trial. Subsequent to this one of these men has died but the case continues to be dragged out in our courts. The snag; Botswana has a mandatory death penalty for convicted murderers.

Our government has appealed to the government of Botswana for a commitment not to pass the death penalty; understandably they refused. This has created a legal dilemma: the men cannot be tried in a South African court, but also cannot be extradited. This has two obvious infringements on human rights. Firstly, the accused could potential get away with murder and the victims not see justice. Secondly, South Africa could become a safe-haven for criminals fleeing potential execution thus our citizens right to safety in infringed upon.

In an attempt to protect human rights, our constitution has actually protected potential murders.

Friday, May 6, 2011

All they have are unenclosed toilets

The Democratic Alliance (DA) presented the residents of Makhaza Township in Cape Town with two choices: either the council builds one toilet to be shared by five families and the council will enclose them, or the council builds one toilet per family and each family enclose them.

The decision made by the community was one toilet per family, enclosed by themselves.

According to the law, the basic human rights of residents of Makhaza were infringed upon by the erection of these unenclosed toilets. I agree with this, despite the fact that the residents agreed to it. The law is the law.

As we get closer to the elections this judgement has given the African National Congress (ANC) much impetus. Opposition parties are referring to trivial matters such as: police brutality, failure to deliver basic services, a crippled health-care system, one of the worst education systems on the continent, rife corruption, and rampant crime (to name one or two). The ANC has chosen to focus on the Makhaza issue and almost every single ANC election rally over the last week has used this judgement to 'prove' that the DA are racist and do not care about black people.

If one looks at it objectively, it seems as if all the ANC have are unenclosed toilets.

Thursday, May 5, 2011

Our democracy needs changing

Essentially there are two kinds of democracy: 1) Proportional Representation and 2) a Constituency system.

After South Africa emerged as a democracy debate raged as to which voting system we would use and the Proportional Representations system was chosen. This system functions essentially along these lines: rather than voting for an individual one votes for a party. According to the percentage (proportion) of the voters that vote for your party equals the percentage of seats you receive in National or local government (assembly). Each party chooses the candidates that they want to represent them.

However, a Constituency system works as follows: every single area of a country is divided into small segments. In each segment an individual politician has to canvass the votes of the people in that segment (constituency). The person who wins the majority of the votes in that segment then becomes the leader and representative for that segment.

In my view the Proportional Representation system it is severely flawed and is challenging our democracy.

Firstly, there is no accountability; when the party or an individual fails to fulfil their promises they hide behind one another and no one is held accountable. This is due to the fact that bad local and national leaders can hide behind the party and the party can hide behind the excuse of 'it was one bad individual'. In the Constituency system the voters know the face and name of their local leader and that person is held accountable if they don't fulfil their promises.

The second reason is that the 'leader' is not answerable to the voter, but rather to the party. As a result the 'leader' has to tow the party line or face loosing their job.

In our current political climate it is essential that politicians start being held accountable, and that is best handled by changing the way that we run our democracy.

Friday, April 29, 2011

Will our President please stand up

No one will dispute that South Africa has come a long way and has set the benchmark for a democratic, peaceful revolution. With great national pride millions went to the ballot box for the first time on the 27th of April 1994. Since then the day has been commemorated as a national day of celebration to remind us of what we have achieved as a nation.

However, this year's celebration was a disgrace.

According to the government's website Freedom Day is celebrated for the following reasons: ... every South African, young and old, to recognise the values and principles enshrined in our constitution and avoid behaviour that may impact negatively on society.
... We celebrate living in a system which guarantees that never again will our human dignity be taken from any South African irrespective of their race, gender, creed or sexual orientation.


None of what the government says we celebrate was expressed at the ceremony this year.

Members of government -from a number of different parties- gathered at the Union Buildings and many were given the opportunity to address the crowd. Whenever a member of an opposition party got to the platform and tried to speak they were heckled, booed and shouted offstage. A lame attempt was made by Arts and Culture Minister Paul Mashatile to calm the crowd but it was to no avail.

This was no political rally, but rather a chance to celebrate our hard fought political freedoms. However, the very thing that was meant to be celebrated was dragged through the mud while our President did nothing.

It is to President Zuma's eternal disgrace that he sat on his chair and watched a national celebration turn into a farce. It seems as if the President is unable to separate his role as President of the Country and President of the ruling party; the two are very distinct. As his role of President of this country it was his duty to defend and protect a national day.

In addition, this was not the first time President Zuma has shown a blatant lack of national leadership. At this year's Human Rights Day celebrations in Cape Town opposition members were booed while the President watched on.

This is totally unacceptable and an embarrassment.

Please Mr President, stand up and lead.

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

ANC needs to be careful with what it says

Due to a shocking series of administrative errors no ANC candidates in Potchefstroom will be running in the upcoming elections. Quite simply no names were handed in to the Independent Electoral Commission (IEC) before the deadline closed. The man accused of this error is ANC provincial secretary for North West Kabelo Mataboge.

In response to the allegations Mataboge acknowledged that the ANC will not be contesting seven of the wards in Potchefstroom and then said, "We hope this is due to human error and not political conspiracy by the IEC" (The Mail and Guardian, 21 to 28 April 2011, page 3). This is a very dangerous comment to be making.

In order for our democracy to survive and flourish there needs to be unwavering faith in the institutions that protect our freedom. Democracy lives and dies on holding free and fair elections and thus the independence of an Electoral Committee is paramount.

As long as the ANC accepts comments such as the one made by Mataboge a platform can be laid to question our election results. As we have seen in so many fledgling democracies, when a set of results come out that are unfavourable to the incumbents then the results are questioned. As soon as results can be questioned there will be room for revolution, coup d’état and civil war.

The ANC need to distance themselves from the comments made by Mataboge and be very careful with the language that they use in future.

Monday, June 7, 2010

Cope good for South Africa

Many of us were so excited a little while ago when the African National Congress (ANC) began to splinter and the Congress of the People (COPE) broke away. For the first time in our young democracy we seemed to have a realistic opposition that could appeal to the black masses. We all thought that the rise of COPE signalled the demise of the ANC's dominance of politics in South Africa.

With the obvious lack of service delivery many supporters of the ANC have been looking for another party to vote and when COPE arrived they found what they thought was a realistic option. However, since their first party conference it has all gone downhill. Leadership battles, policy disagreements and lack of vision have prevented the party from providing the opposition we all hoped they would (or could) be. So now that COPE has all but fallen apart it seems as if the 1.3 odd million people who chose to vote for them wasted their time and will go back to voting for the ANC, or worse, not vote at all.

If we take a superficial look it seems as if the whole process has been a failure. But if we look a little bit deeper into the unraveling of the party we can pull out at least one very positive development for our young democracy: choice.

Many of the ANC supporters would never have thought that they could vote for anyone other than the party that was the catalyst for the downfall of Apartheid; COPE shattered that mindset. They have crossed a line many thought would never be crossed and with any luck we will find that the Rubicon of race politics has been traversed and South Africans will move away from their 'traditional' party.

If nothing else the rise (and fall) of COPE has shattered some mindsets and begun the process of moving to a real democracy where our citizens vote for the best party and not the traditional party.

Monday, May 31, 2010

What is the real South Africa

The other day I couldn't wipe the smile off my face as I watched countless flags flap around cars all over Johannesburg. I was so excited for the scores of foreigners arriving soon to experience the infectious warm-hearted attitude of the people of our wonderful nation. I have been to a number of countries in Europe and no where have I met people as friendly as South Africans.

Then I had a reality check and realised how jaded I (and so many others) have become; I am very hesitant to stop for someone who is broken down on the highway, open my window for beggars or speak to strangers, all for fear of being a victim of crime. I get the feeling that we have lost what makes us such wonderful group of people. We don't trust each other and close ourselves off to those around us; think boomed-off communities. It would be an absolute tragedy if a few hundred thousand tourists don't get experience what we are truly like simply because of a crime problem created by a few thugs and political ineptitude.

I am sick of hearing politicians spew out rubbish about being committed to fixing crime. If the 'powers that be' were really interested in fixing the crime in our country they could; they simply do not have the will. Human beings have proved that if we have a will, then we can make it happen. China was able to increase their literacy rate from about 20% in 1950 to over 90% within 15 years. Literacy is a lot harder to achieve than fixing crime; it involves educating teachers before educating the people. They had the political will and made it happen. Politicians in South Africa have no desire to solve our most burning issue.

There is a problem and there are many possible solutions. I propose one: until the crime situation in South Africa is fixed up politicians should not be permitted to have body-guards and private protection. Take that away and watch the crime-scourge plummet.

Added to this, the same politicians should be forbidden from sending their kids to private schools. How can they justifibly be responsible for government education but not trust it enough to use it themselves. Force these politicians into over-crowded schools and I can guarantee there will be a drastic change in quality.

Thoughts?